Ori-Ori

Characters that attack in training mode.

Papyrus... this is AxSeeker. He's not exactly the best indicator of whether characters are good or not.

Also, I was laughing at the dude's spelling errors, not the fact he needed help coding.

...you are joking, right?
There's no way you can be serious about that.
Unless...did Dark Chaos seriously improve?
Can a second person please check? I'm kinda afraid right now.

I don't see why that's funny. AI coding is ridiculously difficult.
 
Anyway, there's no point in being blunt towards Dark Chaos since his chars are pretty much the same.

Hello TxPot and welcome to MFFA. It's nice to hear that you are still there at PCEA. :3
 
Okay, so it's official now. This are the POKéMON I'm currently working on or are definitive future WIPs:
*Jigglypuff (current WIP)
*Glaceon & Leafeon (comes directly after Jigglypuff)
*Lucario (comes after Glaceon and Leafeon)
*Togetic (very old WIP of mine)
*Ampharos (comes after Togetic)
*Mawile (possible future WIP, if Daeron will come up with the sprites just like he did with Croagunk)
*Sylveon (future joint project WIP, combining JoshR Eeveelution sprites with the efforts of me and Neweegee and possible other people, first X/Y POKéMON in PCEA)
Right now, Jigglypuff is the biggest priority, but there is one problem: Jigglypuff would require a new status effect to be added for the fullgame, and that is sleep.
And sadly, that would require the common1.cns to be updated as well. However, I first need permission for that before I can update it myself with the new status effect sleep (I would also update my Eeveelutions to have displays for the new status effect as well, while every other sleep-related effect will be already applied to the common animation file).

Check. :3

I wouldn't recommend you to put yourself first above everyone. He clearly didn't make the char for only yourself. That speaks about having serious ego problems.
 
Without criticism, there's no evolution in your work.
 
Also, if he practices martial arts or not doesn't make it an excuse to rush his work. People will always criticize because most people expect from the author/artist an improvement of its work. Sure, it's up to him if he wants to improve of not, but he would be committing the same mistakes over and over otherwise.
 
You can tell us we can fix the char if we wanted to, and while that's true, the responsibility always falls into the actual creator instead of the editor.

Yeah no. It doesn't quite work like that, my friend. Sometimes one needs harsh criticism to get better. I, for one learned that the hard way.
 
With that said, direct the topic towards the character, its flaws, etc.

And what are other creators doing? Sorry pal, but it's not going to work here. Also, I wouldn't put myself first than everyone else here if I were you.
 
At this point, you're showing nothing but being a defensive fanboy, and I don't blame you for it, but you have to understand that every creator/artist/author will eventually get criticized for better results. It will continue to exist in any community, especially in this community, and you have to accept that like it or not.

I myself never got to enjoy....

This...i find one of the worst thing i ever watched.

A disappointing and terrible "POTS" Styled character, even though it doesn't play like one.
- Large portrait is incorrect size. - EX moves give back power. - LP can spawn an infinite (if done correctly by punching three times, then dashing forward). - Speaking of dash, this is nothing like POTS' styled dashing at all. - MK has no hitsound. - No Damage Dampener. - Makai Invocation creates debug flood (illegal enemy number in retargeted trigger). - Makai Invocation also spawns an infinite in corner. - Teleport Flash triggers "State 1130 has no root". - All hyper superpauses trigger an illegal superpause time. Also, they don't seem to do much damage. - Evil Hornet Gang's projectiles spawns "has no target with hit ID to -1". - Lightning Lookout spawns "State 1100 has no root". - Makai Invitation spawns "Explod Facing Param must be 1 or -1". - Parry is completely useless. Has an invalid state. - Lv. 3 hyper portrait is just terrible. Completely misaligned. Z+C Level Up just doesn't work like it should be. Really, this feels like testament just copy-pasted everything from KusareMiyabi's version,into a POTS template and just called it a day. This is NOT how you learn how to create a character. If you're going to do it right, you have to learn everything that's happening in the coding.
 
EDIT: Another thing I forgot to mention is the AI, and oh boy, it causes Amakusa to bug out constantly.

- All moves inflict INSANE amount of damage, (Especially her Lv. 1 hyper as stated above)
- B (Crouching) becomes an infinite (if done correctly).
- Ice (All moves) becomes an infinite (if done correctly).
- Ice Cage (All moves) becomes an infinite (if done correctly).
 
Let go of this Elsa please.

Hoh boy. Not Dark Chaos. After testing his past characters with ridiculous AI and infinite priorities, I don't think I want to go through that again. If  you expect his latest characters to be an improvement, then sorry to burst your bubble, but his "CVS" characters aren't any better.

It says "Pillow not included", how was this even marketed?

Spongeachu.

What did you do to TR, they look hideous.


"Spader-Man" that is too funny. 
 

So that's what Saber would look like if her summoning was botched. That just proves that if you want to summon a hero from across time, you don't go the bargain route.

There should be a good marstorius, and a good Green Goblin. In fact, good spiderman villains. Spidey's got a great cast of villains and it sucks that only venom ended up in mvc.

It's not that. she has way too much priority on her attacks, attacks that are way too safe on block and hard to punish, gains power from her supers, way too many defective mechanics (really, a pushblock, MB shield, burst, dodge and roll? pick just one of them Geros) unblockables, a super that coast no power, has long rang and does a lot of damage and other problems I could go on about.    

I know how you feel, Dizzy.
 
And now that I think about it, Geros' Mami is very similar too Yu's Miku. 

Oh, boy, she is? I haven't tried her yet, but I didn't like that Miku at all, so...

So... what are your most disappointing Mugen characters?
 
Mines are:
 
Geros' Mami: the sprites may be good but she is way too overpowered, has way too many defense options and she gain power from her supers.
And ALerkina4's Greninja: no comment.

I agree and disagree with some of the points made here.
Despite maintaining a Kirby MUGEN website, I've yet to find a definitive Kirby, as most are too small. MOC's Kirby's commands are quite difficult to pull off, let alone work, and it plays nothing like KOF (despite the label).
Warner was considered more of a spriter than a coder by many. Warner's Luigi is just an edit of N64Mario's version with bigger sprites. As for Wario, he's one of my MUGEN mains, because I find him easy to use. I do agree that he could use more moves (and maybe an A.I). Also, it's worth it to note that @ndroide is the real one to thank here, as he updated the older version of Wario to what it is today, with Warner putting on more finishing touches.
Homer IS unimaginative. Not to mention that his A.I can barely be called brutal by today's standards.
I find certain moves of DBK's too hard to pull off (the "F***ING PYRON MORPH" being one of them), and he's so combo loose, with the A.I bordering on cheap as a result. Not bad, but- WHO THE F***'S IN MY APARTMENT?!
Pac-Man is enjoyable for me personally.
I agree with Peach.
AMEN for Donald. His hypers are quite cool though. I do think that Sennou-Room did Donald justice with his edit, but I wish that the one KOF XI Oswald reference move replaces one of the level 3s (preferably the QCF QCF P+K).
The Luigi version kinda rendered Super Mario obsolete in my eyes. Not even SM853 or anybody else could save it. IIRC DarkWolf13 and ShinZankuro are editing the character for their fullgames.

YU-TOHARU's Miku
So much potential on those sprites by kabao, but the gameplay itself is where everything about the character is flawed and overly broken. And yes, I'm still hoping for a decent Miku out there to be created.